How to Support Primary Students Who Struggle to Work Independently
Do you have a few little friends in your classroom who have a HARD TIME working independently?
As in…you get everyone started in centers or independent work, and these little friends just can’t seem to get started…or stay engaged and on-task?
If so, you are not alone!
It seems like I always have at least 1 or 2 kids in my class (if not more!) who have a very hard time working independently. And I’ve talked to SO many other teachers who are facing the same challenge!
In my opinion, it’s just as important to teach kids independent work skills as it is to teach academics!
It’s easy to get frustrated when we’ve prepared great independent work activities and thoroughly modeled them—and some kids still don’t get on board. BUT we have to remember that, like any skill, teaching independence takes time.
So in today’s post, I’ll share 3 things I do to help K-2 students improve their independent work skills. (There’s a little freebie for you, too!)
Photo Credit: Dragon Images, Shutterstock
1. Look for possible causes of the behavior, and adjust your strategy accordingly.
If you have a child who is really struggling to stay on-task during independent work time, it’s important to figure out WHY that might be happening.
Consider setting aside 5-10 minutes to observe the child from a distance.
- Is the work too easy or difficult for the child?
- Does the child know what to do?
- Is the child seeking attention from peers or me?
- Does the child struggle with sitting still or attending to one thing for a long period of time?
Based upon what you learn, you might:
- Adjust the difficulty level of activities for the child
- Use small-group or one-on-one reteaching to ensure the child knows how to do activities (or involve the child more actively during whole group demonstrations)
- Teach the child how to appropriately get attention from you and/or peers
- Offer different options to the child to help him/her focus, like allowing the child to stand up to complete activities, use a timer, or allow frequent drink/stretch breaks
2. Track students’ behavior with them, and encourage self-reflection.
If the ideas in #1 don’t yield results, try tracking students’ behavior on a daily basis.
If you’re familiar with the PBIS behavior system, then you might already use “check in/check out” sheets with students.
I know that all schools implement these sheets differently, but if you’re not familiar with them, they are daily sheets that certain students carry with them throughout the school day. After each subject or block of time, the teacher rates the student’s behavior (with student input). These sheets are sometimes used to improve overall behavior, or to focus on a specific goal like participating more in class, or using a quiet voice.
Anyway, the reason I bring up check-in/check-out sheets is because the concept can be applied to helping kids work more independently during centers or other independent work times.
Even if a child doesn’t need a check-in/check-out sheet for the entire day, a simple behavior chart might be helpful for independent work time.
There are lots of ways to implement these, but here’s one strategy:
- Give students their independent work sheets at the beginning of centers. Provide a little reminder about what you expect.
- During centers, keep an eye on these students as much as possible (or get help from an aide/volunteer).
- After centers, have each student come to you individually. Ask the student how he/she thinks it went. With the student, rate his/her behavior. (Have the child mark it on the actual paper, if possible.)
- Do this on a daily basis, until the student reaches a certain goal, like 5 days in a row of smiley faces (you would share this goal with him/her beforehand).
As you can probably guess, this procedure can become unmanageable if you use these sheets with more than 3-4 kids. These behavior sheets are designed to be a support for a small group of students. (If you find that many more of your students are struggling, you might want to adjust your overall approach/strategy for centers.)
Also, if you choose to associate rewards with a behavior sheet, I recommend selecting prizes like getting to eat lunch with you, a special note or phone call home about the excellent behavior, or something along those lines.
We want to develop intrinsic motivation in our students. When I discuss kids’ progress with them, I say things like, “Wow, you must really be proud of yourself” or “You got a whole lot of learning done today because you were so focused!” I try to emphasize their OWN feelings of pride in their accomplishments, rather than communicating that the goal is to make me (the teacher) happy.
If you’re interested in this type of chart, click on the image below to get my free literacy centers toolkit (the chart is included in the download).
3. If all else fails, forget the whole “independent” thing altogether (temporarily).
Let’s say that you’ve tried all of these strategies, and you’re still not getting anywhere. And maybe the child is a) harming other students, or b) distracting other students so that they aren’t getting any work done.
I have been in this situation before, and it’s a tough position to be in—especially if you don’t have an aide or other adult help in the classroom.
On one hand, you want to give the child an opportunity to learn and practice independent work skills. But at the same time, you can’t compromise other students’ rights to safety and learning.
I don’t do this often, but in extreme situations, I will temporarily take away the privilege of independent work.
I’ll explain to the child, “I know that you want to work on your own, just like all the other kids. I want you to do that too. But getting to work on your own is also a privilege. And you’re not showing me that you’re ready for that privilege yet. So for right now, you will be doing your work right by my table. And we will work together to help you practice _________ (staying focused/keeping your hands to yourself/whatever the child’s main problem is). I know you’ll work hard so that you can be with everyone else again!”
Then, I have the child complete the same (or similar) independent work activities—but while sitting on the floor near my guided reading or small group. I have the child face away from the group, so that they don’t distract us. But the student is still close enough for me to supervise.
I hate to isolate kids, so I make sure that this is a temporary intervention. Again, I use it sparingly, and only when other kids’ safety and learning is being affected.
These are my 3 main strategies for helping kids learn to work more independently. What are yours? You can leave your ideas or tips in a comment. I’d love to hear them!